Probably true vs insufficient data
Choose probably true or probably false when the facts lean one way without proving it. Choose insufficient data when the facts do not bear on the claim. Use true or false only when the facts settle it.
A three-question test
- Do the facts prove the inference? Choose true.
- Do the facts rule it out? Choose false.
- Otherwise, do the facts lean toward it or away from it? Choose probably true or probably false. If they say nothing about it, choose insufficient data.
Why people get this wrong
Many candidates use outside knowledge, so a claim feels likely even though the passage never supports it. Others pick insufficient data whenever they feel unsure, even when the numbers lean clearly one way. Both mistakes come from not asking what the facts themselves say.
Worked examples
Example 1
Facts
Mia has taken the 7:40 train to work every weekday for three years and has missed it only twice. Tomorrow is an ordinary Wednesday.
Proposed inference
Mia will take the 7:40 train tomorrow.
Show the answer
Answer: Probably true. She almost always takes it, but tomorrow is not certain.
Example 2
Facts
In each of the last ten years, the town has had between 4 and 8 rainy days in June. June has 30 days.
Proposed inference
Next June will have fewer than 15 rainy days.
Show the answer
Answer: Probably true. Ten years of 8 or fewer rainy days makes fewer than 15 very likely, but not certain.
Example 3
Facts
Mia has taken the 7:40 train to work every weekday for three years and has missed it only twice. Tomorrow is an ordinary Wednesday.
Proposed inference
Mia will miss the 7:40 train tomorrow.
Show the answer
Answer: Probably false. She has missed it only twice in three years, so this is unlikely.
Example 4
Facts
In each of the last ten years, the town has had between 4 and 8 rainy days in June. June has 30 days.
Proposed inference
Next June will have more than 15 rainy days.
Show the answer
Answer: Probably false. Ten years of 8 or fewer rainy days makes this very unlikely, but not impossible.
Example 5
Facts
A survey of 500 office workers found that 320 commute by public transport. Of those 320, 240 said they read or work on their phones during the trip. Of the 180 who do not use public transport, most drive alone.
Proposed inference
Workers who drive alone are more productive than workers who use public transport.
Show the answer
Answer: Insufficient data. Productivity was not measured.
Example 6
Facts
A small town's only bookshop closed last year. Since then, the town library reports a 30% rise in borrowing. The library did not change its opening hours or its collection in that time.
Proposed inference
The library's collection is bigger than the bookshop's stock was.
Show the answer
Answer: Insufficient data. The facts give no sizes.
More on the section: Watson-Glaser Inference guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between probably true and insufficient data in the Watson-Glaser test?
Choose probably true when the facts lean toward the inference but do not prove it. Choose insufficient data when the facts have nothing useful to say about it.
When should I choose insufficient data?
Choose it when the facts do not touch the claim at all, so you would have to guess or bring in outside knowledge.
Is it safe to pick insufficient data when I am unsure?
No. Using it as a default is a common scoring error. First ask whether the facts lean one way.
Sources. Facts about the test come from the test maker's published documents: the Watson-Glaser product page, Pearson's efficacy report (April 2020) and the Watson-Glaser III FAQ (Dutch edition, the one available online). Figures from prep sites or careers pages are unofficial and are labelled as such.
Practise with 666 free questions
Last updated 2026-11-20. This site is not connected to Pearson or TalentLens. Watson-Glaser is their trademark.