Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal

Watson-Glaser Deduction: how it works, with examples

In the Deduction section you treat the premises as true and decide whether a conclusion must follow from them. You choose between two answers: conclusion follows, or conclusion does not follow. Choose follows only when the conclusion is true in every case the premises allow.

How to answer

  1. Accept the premises as true, even if they sound odd.
  2. Note the quantifiers: all, some, no, most.
  3. Picture the groups as overlapping circles, or sketch them.
  4. Choose conclusion follows only if no arrangement of the circles can make it false.

Common mistakes

Worked examples

Read each one, decide your answer, then open the answer.

Example 1

Premises

Some of the runners in the club are teachers. All teachers in the club are early risers.

Proposed conclusion

Some of the runners are early risers.

Show the answer

Answer: Conclusion follows. The runners who are teachers are also early risers.

Example 2

Premises

If it rains, the match is cancelled. The match was not cancelled.

Proposed conclusion

It did not rain.

Show the answer

Answer: Conclusion follows. If it had rained, the match would be cancelled. It was not. So it did not rain.

Example 3

Premises

If it rains, the match is cancelled. The match was cancelled.

Proposed conclusion

It rained.

Show the answer

Answer: Conclusion does not follow. Other things could cancel a match. Rain is only one cause.

Example 4

Premises

All the cats in the shop are tabby. Milo is tabby.

Proposed conclusion

Milo is a cat in the shop.

Show the answer

Answer: Conclusion does not follow. Other tabby animals exist. Milo may not be in the shop.

The other parts of the test: Inference, Recognition of Assumptions, Interpretation, Evaluation of Arguments. See also how to pass the Watson-Glaser test.

Frequently asked questions

What does follows mean in Watson-Glaser Deduction?

It means the conclusion must be true whenever the premises are true. Likely is not enough.

Do I use real-world knowledge?

No. Use only the premises, even when they contradict what you know.

How many answer choices are there?

Two: conclusion follows and conclusion does not follow.

Sources. Facts about the test come from the test maker's published documents: the Watson-Glaser product page, Pearson's efficacy report (April 2020) and the Watson-Glaser III FAQ (Dutch edition, the one available online). Figures from prep sites or careers pages are unofficial and are labelled as such.

Practise with 666 free questions

Last updated 2026-11-20. This site is not connected to Pearson or TalentLens. Watson-Glaser is their trademark.