Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal

Watson-Glaser Evaluation of Arguments: how it works, with examples

In the Evaluation of Arguments section you read a question and an argument for or against it. You decide whether the argument is strong or weak. A strong argument is important and relates directly to the question. A weak argument is trivial, rests on personal preference, or is off the point.

How to answer

  1. Treat the argument as true.
  2. Ask whether it answers this exact question.
  3. Ask whether it matters, and how large the effect could be.
  4. Set your own opinion of the issue aside.

Common mistakes

Worked examples

Read each one, decide your answer, then open the answer.

Example 1

Question

Should employers have to publish salary ranges in job adverts?

Argument

Yes. It helps applicants judge jobs fairly and can show pay gaps.

Show the answer

Answer: Strong argument. Fair pay is a central aim of publishing ranges, and this claim speaks to it.

Example 2

Question

Should the country invest more in public libraries?

Argument

No. Borrowing has fallen for ten years, so the money could help more people elsewhere.

Show the answer

Answer: Strong argument. Falling use of libraries and better use of money both bear on the decision.

Example 3

Question

Should employers have to publish salary ranges in job adverts?

Argument

No. Some people do not like to talk about money.

Show the answer

Answer: Weak argument. Some people's discomfort is not a reason about job adverts.

Example 4

Question

Should the country invest more in public libraries?

Argument

Yes. Libraries are quiet and I like the smell of books.

Show the answer

Answer: Weak argument. Liking the smell of books is a private preference.

The other parts of the test: Inference, Recognition of Assumptions, Deduction, Interpretation. See also how to pass the Watson-Glaser test.

Frequently asked questions

What makes an argument strong in the Watson-Glaser test?

It is important and directly related to the question, and it would still matter if it were true.

Do I need to agree with the argument?

No. Judge its strength, not whether you agree.

How many answer choices are there?

Two: strong argument and weak argument.

Sources. Facts about the test come from the test maker's published documents: the Watson-Glaser product page, Pearson's efficacy report (April 2020) and the Watson-Glaser III FAQ (Dutch edition, the one available online). Figures from prep sites or careers pages are unofficial and are labelled as such.

Practise with 666 free questions

Last updated 2026-11-20. This site is not connected to Pearson or TalentLens. Watson-Glaser is their trademark.